Does Soy Cause Cancer and Other Myths

April 30, 2024

One topic we have to dive into together is soy. A question that gets asked most often is “does soy cause cancer?” Or “is soy bad for men’s health and testosterone?” There are so many opinions and thoughts on soy, and they seem to take on a life of their own! Before we explore soy’s scientifically proven benefits and roles, we must address these widespread misconceptions head-on.

As plant-based diets continue to increase in popularity, understanding the role of soy becomes even more essential. Soy is a fantastic source of protein and offers numerous nutritional benefits for a vegan or plant-based lifestyle. Let’s sift through the myths and facts to uncover the real impact of soy on our health.

Myth 1: Soy Causes Breast Cancer

The Misconception: Many people ask this question: “does soy cause cancer?” It’s a common concern that eating soy can increase the risk of breast cancer due to its isoflavones, which are phytoestrogens similar to estrogen. Because high levels of estrogen have been linked to breast cancer, many assume that phytoestrogens could similarly increase cancer risk.

The Reality: Let’s unpack the science to dispel this myth. Soy’s phytoestrogens, particularly genistein, act as natural selective estrogen receptor modulators. They can have pro-estrogenic effects in bones and anti-estrogenic effects in breast tissue. Importantly, soy phytoestrogens bind to the estrogen beta receptor, not the alpha receptor linked to breast cancer risk.

Scientific Backing: Research shows soy consumption does not increase breast cancer risk; it may actually lower it.¹² Studies highlight that genistein levels in the blood primarily activate beta receptors, not alpha receptors. The Journal of the American Medical Association shows that soy consumption lowers the risk of death and recurrence in women with breast cancer.³

Conclusion: The answer to the question “does soy cause cancer?” is no. On the contratry, soy is a valuable part of a cancer-aware diet. Understanding how soy interacts with estrogen receptors helps us appreciate its health benefits and cancer protection.

Myth 2: Soy is Bad for Men’s Health

The Misconception: Another widespread myth is that soy negatively impacts men’s health by reducing testosterone levels and affecting fertility. This myth is fueled by the concern that soy’s phytoestrogens could mimic estrogen too strongly, leading to hormonal imbalances in men.

The Reality: Scientific evidence strongly disproves this claim. Research shows consuming soy foods does not lower testosterone levels or harm male reproductive health. Phytoestrogens, although similar to estrogen, have a very weak effect in the human body, especially in men.

Scientific Backing: Many studies have investigated the impact of soy on men’s hormone levels and reproductive health.⁴ A review in Fertility and Sterility concludes that soy consumption does not affect circulating testosterone levels in men.⁵

Conclusion: The fear that soy products emasculate men is unfounded and unsupported by scientific research. Men can enjoy soy products without worrying about negative effects on hormonal health or fertility. Including soy in a balanced diet offers health benefits, like lowering cholesterol levels and providing plant-based protein.

Myth 3: Soy Causes Thyroid Issues

The Misconception: Many claim that soy consumption can lead to thyroid problems, like hypothyroidism. This myth comes from the idea that soy compounds can interfere with thyroid hormone production or absorption, especially in individuals with iodine deficiency.

The Reality: Soy contains goitrogens—substances that can interfere with thyroid hormone production—but its impact on thyroid health mainly concerns those with inadequate iodine intake. Research shows soy has minimal influence on thyroid function in individuals who consume enough iodine.

Scientific Backing: A comprehensive review by Thyroid confirms soy foods are safe for most people, including those with thyroid conditions, if they consume adequate iodine.⁶ Clinical studies show that soy does not cause thyroid dysfunction in people with sufficient iodine in their diets.⁷ Moreover, any potential effects on thyroid function are usually mild and clinically insignificant.⁸⁹

Conclusion: The idea that soy regularly causes thyroid health problems is largely a myth. To ensure thyroid health while consuming soy, individuals should make sure they have adequate iodine in their diet, which is essential for healthy thyroid function. Thus, soy can be a part of a healthy diet, even for those monitoring their thyroid health, provided that their iodine intake is maintained.

Myth 4: All Soy is Genetically Modified and Unhealthy

The Misconception: There is a widespread belief that all soy products are genetically modified organisms (GMOs) and therefore unhealthy. This myth stems from concerns about the potential health risks associated with consuming GMO foods, which some people believe are less nutritious or could contribute to various health issues.

The Reality: While a significant portion of soy grown worldwide is genetically modified, not all soy products are GMOs. Many non-GMO soy options are available, including organic soy products grown without genetic modification. Actually, most GMO soy is fed to livestock and doesn’t end up in the supermarket. Both GMO and non-GMO soy can be part of a healthy diet. Scientific studies find no significant health differences between GMO and non-GMO foods.

Scientific Backing: Extensive research, including studies by the World Health Organization and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, concludes that GMO foods currently available on the market are safe to eat and nutritionally equivalent to their non-GMO counterparts.¹⁰¹¹ Moreover, soy is a rich source of protein, vitamins, and minerals—whether it is genetically modified or not.

Conclusion: The notion that all soy is genetically modified and unhealthy is a myth. Consumers looking to avoid GMOs can opt for certified organic or non-GMO labeled soy products. Understanding the facts about GMOs and non-GMOs can help individuals make informed dietary choices based on science rather than misinformation.

Recap

Well, that was a lot to cover and debunk! Kudos if you made it to the end! For those who might not have the time but still want to capture the essence of our discussion, here’s a super short recap:

Breast Cancer: Soy does not increase your risk of breast cancer; it may actually help reduce it.
Men’s Health: No, soy won’t affect your testosterone or fertility; it’s safe and healthy for men.
Thyroid Health: Soy is fine for your thyroid as long as your diet includes sufficient iodine.
GMO Concerns: Not all soy is GMO, but both GMO and non-GMO soy are safe and nutritious.

Soy is not just a healthy part of a vegan or plant-based diet; it’s a nutrient-rich, versatile food that supports overall health. Whether you sprinkle soy nuts on your salad, enjoy a tofu stir-fry, or sip a soy latte, you do something good for your body. Embrace the real, evidence-backed benefits of soy and enjoy the variety it brings to our tables!

Free download!

If you are curious about plant-based eating, download my Starter’s Guide, where you’ll find recipes, tips & tricks, my favourite kitchen tools and much more!

I'm Dr. Sharon Facey

I’m a Family Doctor with a twist: I’m all in on plant-based nutrition. Discovering how simple dietary changes can prevent common diseases and elevate overall health was a game-changer for me. My mission? To guide you to a healthier version of yourself, proving that vibrant health is achievable in your everyday life!

What do you want to read today?

FREE GUIDE!

6 Ways to Lower Your Cholesterol Naturally

I broke down the 6 most effective, natural strategies to lower your cholesterol into simple, actionable steps so you can start making heart-healthy changes today. ♥️